San Francisco Muni set to make cuts in all divisions

Image credit: SFMTA

With time running out for San Francisco's transportation agency to patch a $322 million deficit, top brass called for wide-ranging cuts that could affect station cleanliness and maintenance of buses and trains.

"The work ahead will not be easy," wrote Bree Mawhorter, Chief Financial Officer of the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA), in a memo to staff and the Board of Directors. She instructed all divisions to cut between 5% and 7% of their budgets, generating enough savings to shore up the transit system until voters decide whether to fund it long-term.

For the past year, officials at the SFMTA have faced a deepening financial quandary. Riders have slowly returned since the pandemic, but not at the level that Muni saw in 2019. COVID emergency funding is about to dry up. Although state lawmakers are pressing for a regional transit tax to hit Bay Area ballots next fall, and San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie is planning a separate local revenue measure to support Muni, none of that money is guaranteed.

If both the city and regional measures pass, it would take until fiscal year 2027 for the tax revenue to flow in. That's too late to fill the $322 million hole anticipated when the next budget cycle begins in July.

Muni will see some relief from a $750 million loan the Legislature is splitting among Bay Area transit agencies, but it won't be enough to solve San Francisco's predicament. All the projected revenue from both ballot measures would still leave SFMTA with a $100 million shortfall.

"We've been talking about this fiscal cliff for a long time," Mawhorter said. "And now, here we are. We are at it." SFMTA leaders are committed to avoid cutting transit service, Mawhorter said, meaning they won't pare back schedules or decrease the number of buses and trains running through San Francisco. Agency staff already had to reduce trips on four bus lines early this year, partially restoring a couple of them this month. Over the summer, SFMTA salvaged about $7 million with another round of trimming, consolidating two bus lines and shortening three others.

Even these moderate changes to service drew a backlash, and the agency took pains to save money in other ways — namely by eliminating 500 positions, including 30 manager posts, and raising the price of metered parking. If the SFMTA aims to preserve the quantity of transit service going forward, the quality still might slip as each division slashes at least 5% of its resources. In the coming years, the agency might have limited ability to hire janitors, mechanics or maintenance workers. It may take longer to fix a broken sign or a dilapidated bus shelter, and crucial repairs could get kicked down the road.

Board directors for SFMTA will hold two workshops, in October and December, to brainstorm revenue ideas and identify what programs could be clawed back in order to create a financial retaining wall.

Source: SFMTA