SFMTA reports challenges with Potrero Yard Modernization Project amidst funding cuts

Image credit: SFMTA

As one-time pandemic relief funds run out, the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA, Muni) faces a budget deficit of about $307 million. The agency is making cost saving reductions to avoid devastating cuts to Muni service. That means making hard choices for infrastructure projects including the Potrero Yard Modernization Project.

The SFMTA needs to replace the 110-year-old Potrero bus yard to create a safe, efficient hub for the trolley buses. The yard is obsolete and one of the most vulnerable facilities in an earthquake. The new yard will: 

  • Maintain electric trolley bus fleet, with space for two-thirds more buses;
  • Improve Muni’s reliability; and
  • Provide safe conditions for staff.

The current scope of the project is not affordable so SFMTA is proposing changes that would reduce the amount of housing that could be built at the new yard. This approach would preserve up to 100 units of proposed affordable housing at the project site. Construction costs, interest rates and market volatility have all escalated since the project started. Costs will continue increasing. More delays would jeopardize the entire project.  

The SFMTA has partnered with the Potrero Neighborhood Collective (PNC) developer team on this project. PNC will pay the upfront costs to build the bus yard. The SFMTA will then repay them over time, spreading the costs over a 30-year period. However, the construction cost and these annual payments must be affordable to the SFMTA. The predevelopment agreement with PNC expires on March 31, 2026. If the deal expires, it would be hard to find a new deal that offers similar financing options.

The SFMTA and the developer team have identified the following areas for savings to create a path to feasibility for the project: removing the podium; reducing the size of the basement and mezzanine level; eliminating the roof; as well as removing operations and maintenance from the deal structure.

The SFMTA is also finding more cost-effective ways to lay out the new bus yard. Reducing the size of the basement and the mezzanine level and removing the roof would significantly decrease construction costs without impacting transit operations. The SFMTA is also taking on operating and maintaining the facility and building systems using our own staff, which results in significant cost savings.

Source: SFMTA