GAO Report recommends FEMA improve transparency of grant decisions
The U.S. Government Accountability Office, the supreme audit institution of the federal government of the United States, has reported that Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) needs to improve transparency in the award of grants under the Transit Security Program.
The National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2022 includes a provision for GAO to review FEMA's management of the Transit Security Grant Program and assess how grant-funded projects improve public transit security.
The Transit Security Grant Program is a discretionary grant program that provides grants to public transit agencies to protect critical transportation infrastructure and the traveling public from terrorism. FEMA awarded nearly three-quarters of grants ($614 million) to transit agencies for law enforcement activities ($245.2 million) and equipment ($211.5 million) from fiscal years 2015 through 2021. FEMA awarded remaining grants for infrastructure projects, training and exercises, public awareness campaigns, and planning.
While FEMA's award process was consistent with some relevant federal grant requirements, it did not meet other requirements for transparency. Specifically, FEMA did not accurately describe its grant scoring criteria in the FY 2021 NOFO. Further, FEMA described the merit review process to competitively score applications in its NOFO, but did not use the results of its process as the sole basis for award decisions.
In FY 2021, FEMA assessed physical terrorist threats to transit agencies, as well as their vulnerabilities to, and the estimated consequences of, an attack, but did not consider cyber threats in its risk model. FEMA could better reflect the nature of current threats to transit agencies if it included cyber threats in the assessment. In addition, FEMA did not document the underlying assumptions and justifications.
GAO is making the following four recommendations for FEMA to the Secretary of Homeland Security (DHS):
- Accurately describe all the criteria used to score applications in the NOFO;
- Select applications for award in accordance with its publically disclosed merit review process;
- Incorporate cyber threats into its risk assessment; and
- Document underlying assumptions and justifications for risk assessment.
- DHS concurred with GAO's recommendations.
Source: GAO










